News

Ithaca man pleads guilty to manslaughter in 2021 killing

Ithaca man pleads guilty to manslaughter in 2021 killing

Photo: Saga Communications, WHCU


ITHACA, N.Y. (WHCU) – An Ithaca man pleads guilty to first degree manslaughter.

41-year-old William Marshall admitted to intentionally causing the death of Alan Godfrey in Tompkins County Court Thursday. Godfrey was found fatally shot near Taughannock Boulevard early on the morning of July 20th, 2021, setting off a months-long investigation.  Marshall was previously charged with second degree murder before his trial was delayed.

“The defendant brutally killed Alan Godfrey and devastated his entire family,” said Tompkins County District Attorney Matthew Van Houten. “In pleading guilty today, the defendant accepted responsibility and will be held accountable for taking Alan’s life. This resolution will also spare Alan’s family from an extremely traumatic and upsetting trial.”

The prosecution will seek the maximum 25-year sentence in State Prison for the crime, along with 5 years of post-release supervision. Marshall was required to waive his right to appeal. He’s currently serving a 33-month sentence for a 2022 federal gun conviction for possessing a firearm as a prior convicted felon. He’ll remain in Tompkins County Jail until sentencing.

“The most important consideration to me is that Alan’s family supports the plea to First Degree Manslaughter,” said Van Houten. “Nothing the justice system can do will ever feel like enough of a punishment for what William Marshall did. But we intend to vigorously argue for the maximum sentence of 25 years in prison.”

Marshall’s sentencing hearing is scheduled for April 13th and 14th, 2023, before Tompkins County Judge Joseph R. Cassidy.

Recent Headlines

18 hours ago in Entertainment

Inside the all-civilian ‘Traitors’: 80,000 applicants and a hands-off castle

NBC is sending more civilians to the Scottish castle: "The Traitors: New Blood" has been renewed for a second season, set to air in 2027, with Alan Cumming back as host.

18 hours ago in Lifestyle

(Not) up in the air: Travelers’ trepidations spike as Thanksgiving nears and tech hiccups abound

At this point, it's practically as much of a Thanksgiving tradition as turkey and stuffing — crowded airports, long lines, jam-packed flights, the ever-present worry about delays and cancellations and extra expenses.

22 hours ago in Education, Entertainment, Local, Sports

Cornell football nears game at Columbia

Both teams have experienced recent struggles.